Bottomline Scores

In every issue, we review a race in great detail. We have weighed various aspects of a marathon within a 1,000-point scoring grid. Besides the author of the article, two dozen runners at the race were randomly chosen to score the race for us.

Here are the Codes with their explanations:

HT = History/Tradition: Evaluate the race’s sense of history and tradition.
EF = Entry Form: Is the race entry form clear, concise, attractive, complete, and easy to fill out?
EC = Entry Cost: For most races, the entry fee covers between 30 and 50 percent of the cost of putting on the event. Rate the value of your dollar relative to this race.
LS = Locale/Scenics: s the race held in an area that is easy to get to and scenic and offers adequate food and housing services and nonrace activities for family and friends?
RG = Registration: Is registration well organized and efficient? Does it bog down unnecessarily?
PA = Prerace activities: Evaluate activities, such as pasta feeds, parties, and so on, during the days before the race.
EX = Expo: Does the expo offer a fair number and variety of booths relative to the race’s size? Are there quality exhibitors and good guest speakers?
CO = Course: Take into consideration the following: degree of difficulty, certified, sanctioned, quality of road or trail surface, adequate mileage and directional markers, aid stations, medical coverage, race communications, accessibility to course for friends and family, typical weather, and so on.
RA = Race Amenities: This category includes race T-shirt, finisher’s medal, finisher’s certificate, adequate and efficient finish area, ease of sweatbag retrieval, showers, postrace refreshments, awards ceremony, raffles, results postcard, results book, and so on.
VO = Volunteers: Are the volunteers experienced and adequate in number?

* race no longer held ** race replaced with new event

Race	Issue	HT	EF	EC	LS	RG	PA	EX	CO	RA	VO	Total	Max
Adirondack Marathon	5.2	20	20	30	45	20	40	30	300	250	90	845	1000
Airforce Marathon	15.3	25	19	28	45	17	45	39	345	232	98	893	1000
Aspen Fila Skymarathon*	4.1	25	15	30	50	20	45	NA	363	235	80	863	950
Atlanta Marathon	4.5	25	20	30	47	18	19	40	375	170	96	840	1000
Austin Marathon	5.6	19	19	27	41	19	41	41	351	228	90	876	1000
Bataan Memorial Death March Marathon	10.1	29	18	27	27	18	28	27	351	225	98	868	1000
Bellingham Bay Marathon	14.3	14	19	27	48	20	18	23	352	201	98	820	1000
Big Sur International Marathon	6.6	24	19	25	49	19	44	44	372	243	98	937	1000
Boulder Backroads Marathon	7.4	18	20	26	44	19	35	33	357	241	93	886	1000
Calgary Marathon	3.2	25	17	28	38	19	45	41	345	238	80	876	1000
California International Marathon	13.5	27	20	26	47	18	38	41	360	223	93	893	1000
Cape Cod Marathon	7.5	24	19	26	45	17	36	36	341	221	98	863	1000
Capital City Marathon	11.1	15	18	26	43	19	14	38	382	238	96	863	950
Charlotte's Thunder Road Marathon	14.5	26	20	30	44	14	34	36	320	211	100	835	1000
Cincinnati Flying Pig Marathon	3.6	24	20	25	46	17	42	43	364	220	100	901	1000
Columbus Marathon	8.4	22	19	25	44	17	37	40	362	201	99	866	1000
Country Music Marathon	14.6	20	20	20	48	20	25	45	375	230	95	898	1000
Cowtown Marathon	13.6	27	20	21	46	20	35	33	288	189	78	757	1000
Crater Lake Marathon	7.3	26	19	28	46	20	22	NA	350	195	96	790	950
Dallas White Rock Marathon	4.6	23	14	28	43	18	36	33	344	220	97	856	1000
Deadwood Mickelson Trail Marathon	18.2	27	19	29	45	20	33	36	373	210	96	888	1000
Des Moines Marathon	19.3	20	20	27	45	18	48	45	370	230	100	923	1000
Detroit Free Press Marathon	5.3	26	17	27	37	17	37	41	372	219	99	892	1000
Disney Marathon	10.3	26	18	26	47	20	39	34	366	233	97	906	1000
Edge to Edge Marathon	12.3	25	9	23	48	20	47	NA	330	193	100	805	950
Edmonton Marathon	2.2	15	18	28	46	18	48	5	313	241	82	814	1000
Eugene Marathon	19.2	26	17	28	44	16	40	44	365	234	98	912	1000
First Light Marathon	17.6	22	19	29	43	19	35	33	362	216	99	877	1000
Fort Lauderdale A1A Marathon	16.6	28	18	29	49	20	35	35	348	220	95	877	1000
Fox Cities Marathon	3.4	25	20	30	50	20	35	20	340	225	100	865	1000
Glass City Marathon	6.1	26	19	28	42	19	38	26	350	220	94	862	1000
God's Country Marathon	6.2	28	17	30	46	17	22	NA	285	175	75	695	950
Governor's Cup Ghost Town Marathon	2.1	28	19	30	45	18	20	25	311	208	91	795	1000
Grand Island Trail Marathon	18.5	15	18	25	50	20	30	NA	350	200	85	793	950
Grandfather Mountain Marathon	10.2	29	19	29	45	16	45	NA	350	200	95	828	950
Grandma's Marathon	3.1	27	19	25	42	19	49	42	395	250	100	968	1000
Hartford Marathon	6.3	27	20	30	47	16	47	44	338	229	100	898	1000
Hatfield-McCoy Marathon	17.2	30	20	27	42	19	43	NA	313	190	100	784	950
Honolulu Marathon	2.4	22	19	22	50	16	48	35	350	245	99	906	1000
Houston Marathon	9.6	27	19	25	48	19	44	49	383	243	96	953	1000
Humboldt Redwoods Marathon	2.3	25	19	30	49	15	18	1	360	211	81	809	1000
Hyannis Marathon	18.6	30	20	30	35	18	40	45	380	200	100	898	1000
Idaho Great Potato Marathon	7.2	23	16	28	42	18	27	NA	322	208	87	771	950
ING New York City Marathon	12.5	28	19	21	46	20	47	41	351	158	100	831	1000
Kiawah Island Marathon	6.5	22	20	25	45	20	39	22	341	209	83	826	1000
Kilauea Volcano Marathon	11.3	25	18	28	30	12	25	NA	300	250	100	788	950
Lake Tahoe Marathon	6.4	17	19	26	49	17	45	39	359	206	90	867	1000
Lakefront Marathon	9.3	25	20	29	46	20	32	33	365	230	98	898	1000
Las Vegas International Marathon	1.5	25	18	25	50	20	39	38	335	205	77	832	1000
Lehigh Valley Health Network Via Marathon	18.3	20	18	24	35	15	40	40	345	200	89	826	1000
Lincoln Marathon	8.6	25	19	26	42	19	32	36	330	225	89	843	1000
Little Rock Marathon	15.6	29	20	30	44	20	42	43	349	246	100	923	1000
Los Angeles Marathon	8.1	21	19	25	37	17	38	39	295	208	89	788	1000
Lost Dutchman Marathon	15.5	30	18	28	45	19	40	35	345	225	90	875	1000
Maine Marathon	10.4	23	19	28	48	20	29	NA	334	198	100	799	950
Marathon to Marathon	16.2	26	15	28	48	20	32	NA	320	235	100	824	950
Mardi Gras Marathon	7.1	23	19	25	47	15	19	33	333	233	90	837	1000
Marine Corps Marathon	11.2	29	19	27	47	9	48	41	375	209	100	904	1000
Missoula Marathon	15.2	19	19	28	48	16	22	33	364	219	99	857	1000
Mohawk Hudson River Marathon	14.4	10	20	20	30	20	25	NA	325	176	82	708	950
Mount Desert Island Marathon	16.4	29	20	28	50	20	45	34	380	245	100	951	1000
Napa Valley Marathon	2.5	28	20	23	50	17	40	40	375	230	90	913	1000
Niagara Falls International Marathon	11.4	28	19	23	50	20	40	44	363	223	97	907	1000
Ocala Marathon*	7.6	18	18	30	41	20	25	NA	352	209	97	810	950
Ocean State Marathon	5.5	26	20	29	46	20	35	25	350	240	95	886	1000
Omaha Marathon	17.4	20	15	25	45	18	40	45	350	200	90	848	1000
Paavo Nurmi Marathon	13.3	30	19	30	44	19	48	NA	347	219	92	848	950
Pacific Shoreline Marathon	10.6	20	18	24	48	20	41	46	379	240	93	929	1000
Park City Marathon	8.2	19	17	28	47	16	30	27	352	210	91	837	1000
Philadelphia Marathon	1.4	19	17	23	44	19	39	33	336	212	96	838	1000
Pike's Peak Marathon	14.1	29	18	24	48	20	38	30	387	215	97	906	1000
Pittsburgh Marathon**	1.6	28	19	28	48	18	40	28	365	235	95	904	1000
Pocatello Marathon	16.3	18	20	27	46	19	42	34	373	244	97	920	1000
Portland Marathon	3.3	27	20	30	40	18	48	35	375	250	100	943	1000
Quad Cities Marathon	4.3	20	20	30	42	18	40	35	371	216	93	885	1000
Race	Issue	HT	EF	EC	LS	RG	PA	EX	CO	RA	VO	Total	Max
Richmond Marathon	9.4	28	19	25	45	8	39	29	373	312	91	870	1000
Rite Aid Cleveland Marathon	12.1	24	19	25	44	20	36	41	348	203	95	855	1000
Rock 'n' Roll Marathon San Diego	9.1	26	20	29	49	18	42	47	368	225	95	919	1000
Rocket City Marathon	11.5	25	19	29	44	19	43	38	351	237	97	902	1000
Royal Victoria Marathon	5.4	25	20	30	50	18	45	10	375	250	95	918	1000
San Antonio Marathon	10.5	23	19	25	46	18	49	40	230	222	91	763	1000
San Francisco Marathon	1.2	27	18	27	50	20	46	45	377	208	88	903	1000
Santa Clarita Marathon	4.4	15	18	30	47	20	45	31	330	235	95	866	1000
Scheels Fargo Marathon	16.1	27	19	27	47	19	46	46	349	233	99	912	1000
Select Medical Corporation Harrisburg Marathon	12.4	25	19	30	45	20	40	40	350	210	99	878	1000
Shamrock Sportsfest Marathon	2.6	28	18	29	39	16	47	45	325	240	79	866	1000
Shiprock Marathon	15.1	25	17	28	45	19	NA	NA	359	225	90	808	900
Silver State Marathon	9.2	30	19	25	50	18	NA	NA	310	228	98	778	900
Sioux Falls Marathon	19.4	20	20	25	45	20	30	30	350	150	95	785	1000
Space Coast Marathon	9.5	24	19	25	45	19	38	NA	347	209	89	815	950
St. George Marathon	13.2	30	19	30	41	19	38	38	385	127	100	937	1000
St. Jude Memphis Marathon	16.5	28	20	28	50	18	40	40	370	230	100	924	1000
Steamboat Marathon	12.2	25	20	26	48	18	42	NA	308	212	93	792	950
Steamtown Marathon	3.5	22	19	28	44	20	46	31	371	212	99	892	1000
Stinson Beach Marathon	18.4	26	18	28	50	18	10	0	400	195	98	843	950
Tacoma City Marathon	17.1	25	20	26	44	14	42	36	351	236	93	887	1000
Tallahassee Marathon	17.5	20	19	30	40	15	25	20	310	200	100	779	1000
Top of Utah Marathon	17.3	24	19	28	44	18	35	34	359	233	97	891	1000
Tucson Marathon	12.6	17	17	23	50	19	36	38	358	200	85	842	1000
Twin Cities Marathon	8.3	25	19	25	50	20	40	48	350	213	98	888	1000
Under Armour Baltimore Marathon	13.4	18	19	25	41	17	37	41	357	216	93	864	1000
Valley of Fire Marathon	15.4	10	15	20	45	18	20	NA	350	200	100	788	1000
Vancouver International Marathon	1.1	25	15	29	47	20	44	40	297	238	96	851	1000
Vermont City Marathon	4.2	25	18	25	46	17	45	38	353	225	96	888	1000
Windermere Marathon	19.1	25	20	25	50	20	26	44	374	224	100	908	1000
Wineglass Marathon	1.3	19	18	25	43	19	34	30	344	217	90	839	1000
Yakima River Canyon Marathon	18.1	26	20	28	43	19	43	n/a	370	222	99	870	950
Yonkers Marathon	8.5	25	19	30	38	19	NA	NA	329	199	92	751	900
Yukon River Trail Marathon	5.1	25	20	30	50	20	30	20	355	225	95	870	1000

Marathon and Beyond

Run Longer, Better, Smarter

Bottomline Scores

Sign up for our newsletter

Connect

What is M&B’s Mission?

Blog Categories